finished

The Secret History

mood ✦ dark academia
started 2023-09-01
finished 2023-09-22
  • classics
  • dark
  • favourites
  • reread-worthy

"Does such a thing as 'the fatal flaw,' that showy dark crack running down the middle of a life, exist outside literature?"

— The Secret History

✦ my review

I finished this in three weeks which, for me, is basically a sprint. There's something about Tartt's prose that makes you feel like you're wearing a velvet coat indoors while it rains outside — decadent and slightly guilty. The whole book is a study in how badly you can want to belong somewhere, and what you'll do when you finally do. Richard Papen is a disaster and I love him for it. I've thought about the opening line roughly three hundred times since finishing.

I came to The Secret History the way most people seem to — someone pressed it into my hands and said “you have to read this” in the tone that allows no refusal. They were right, annoyingly.

What I didn’t expect was how funny it is in places. There’s a dry wit buried under all the Greek tragedy and murder that kept catching me off guard. Bunny is a monster and also somehow the most memorable character in the book.

I underlined something on almost every other page. My copy is now a sad, beloved wreck of margin notes and folded corners.

Would recommend to: anyone who has ever wanted to be part of something slightly dangerous and very beautiful. Anyone who grew up wanting to attend a fictional New England liberal arts college. Anyone who likes their mysteries served backwards with a side of moral philosophy.

Would not recommend to: people who need their protagonists to be good people. People who want something cheerful. My mother.