"Wasn't that what it meant to love someone? That you wanted them to be happy even when their happiness meant that you were absent from it?"
✦ my review
I'm going to be honest: I don't know if 'enjoyed' is the right word for this book. I experienced it. It sat in my chest for weeks like a stone. Yanagihara does something genuinely difficult here — she writes about suffering in a way that doesn't feel exploitative, even when it should. Jude St. Francis is a character I will never forget, and I say that as someone who spent significant portions of this 800-page novel actively trying to take breaks from it. The friendship between the four men is the most tender thing. That's what makes the rest of it so unbearable in the best way.
I started this in January thinking it would take me a month. It took five weeks, which includes about four days where I couldn’t pick it up because I was still recovering from the previous session.
Some books you read. Some books happen to you. This one happened to me, repeatedly, with what I can only describe as careful, patient cruelty.
Things that helped me survive it:
- Keeping a soft blanket nearby at all times
- Having a comfort read queued up for immediately after
- Texting my best friend “are you OKAY” at 1am (she had already read it, she said “no, never again, and also yes read it”)
The rating is 4 stars and not 5 because: I genuinely cannot tell if Yanagihara was making a point about suffering or just… doing it. But I can’t stop thinking about it, so maybe that’s the point.
If you read this, I am sending you a little care package of emotional support from across the internet.